Between the Lines 9: Winter Sleep

In our ninth Between the Lines gathering, we explored Nuri Bilge Ceylan’s film Winter Sleep, set against the breathtaking landscape of Cappadocia, where people share the same roof yet remain emotionally distant from one another.

Through the characters’ thought-provoking conversations, we reflected on pride, power, kindness, conscience, wealth and poverty.

Are You Ready to Wake Up?

Hibernation is nature’s way of slowing down to protect itself. But can we, too, retreat into a kind of mental or emotional hibernation?

At the centre of the film is Aydın, an educated, wealthy and cultured man with opinions about almost everything. Yet he seems remarkably unaware of the lives unfolding right beside him.

One participant highlighted the irony of his name: Aydın means “enlightened” in Turkish.

But what does being enlightened really mean? Knowing a great deal, or being able to truly see ourselves and others?

Hibernation might represent introspection and deeper self-awareness. Equally, it might mean remaining in a familiar yet uncomfortable life without taking steps towards change.

Could choosing not to see what is right in front of us be another form of sleep?

The Aydın Within Us

Aydın attracted considerable criticism during our conversation. His arrogance, condescending attitude and constant need to justify himself made many of us uncomfortable.

Yet another perspective gradually emerged.

Was Aydın really so different from the others? While Necla criticised her brother, how aware was she of her own struggles? While Nihal searched for meaning, how honestly did she confront her needs and contradictions?

One participant’s observation, “Perhaps we are all Aydın, in some way,” shifted our perspective.

It is easy to recognise behaviours that disturb us in others. What is harder is acknowledging those same behaviours in ourselves.

The arguments in which we insist on being right, the conversations in which we pretend to listen, the moments when we treat our perspective as the only truth…

How much we resemble Aydın.

The Unseen Side of Aydın

Despite our criticism, we began to recognise Aydın’s vulnerability beneath his powerful, self-assured exterior.

He was also a man who felt belittled by his sister, unseen by his wife, and deeply in need of appreciation and love.

One participant observed:

“Perhaps Aydın is not seen because he fails to see those around him.”

We all want to be understood, valued and appreciated. Yet sometimes our own needs become so overwhelming that we fail to recognise those of others.

During Nihal and Aydın’s lengthy confrontation, both were speaking. But were they truly listening?

When defending ourselves or proving ourselves right becomes more important than understanding, genuine communication begins to disappear.

Doing Good or Looking Good?

One of the film’s most striking scenes is when İsmail throws into the fire the money Nihal has brought to help his family.

Some of us saw his pride, others her helplessness, and others the power imbalance between giver and receiver.

Had the money been accepted, Nihal might have felt reassured that she had done something good. Its rejection removed that comfort.

This raised an uncomfortable question: Is our desire to help sometimes connected to our need to see ourselves as good people?

Helping others can make us feel better. But beyond occasional acts of kindness, how genuine and consistent are our efforts to improve the world we share?

Do we truly understand what others need, or simply offer what we believe is right?

When Being Right Prevents Understanding

Our actions do not always reflect the values we express.

Aydın writes about how religious leaders should behave but struggles to understand the circumstances of the imam nearby.

Necla judges others while avoiding her own difficulties.

Nihal tries to rescue people from poverty while remaining trapped in a life she finds unfulfilling.

Perhaps what matters is not proving ourselves right, but finding the courage to look honestly at ourselves.

Can We Recognise Life’s Mirrors?

One participant reflected on the captured horse’s struggle and Aydın’s later decision to release it.

The horse seemed to mirror Aydın himself: trapped, longing for freedom, yet struggling to escape his circumstances.

For some, Aydın’s return to writing suggested a return to familiar patterns rather than genuine transformation.

Is awareness alone enough to create change?

Life constantly offers us mirrors through relationships, conflicts and unexpected experiences. Whether we choose to look, acknowledge what we see and act differently remains our responsibility.

How Do We Begin to Wake Up?

As our gathering drew to a close, one participant’s words stayed with us:

“Wake up from your mind’s winter sleep.”

The film encouraged us to question the truths we ignore, the patterns we repeat and the beliefs we hold too tightly.

Our desire to see ourselves as good, right or knowledgeable can sometimes prevent us from truly knowing ourselves.

Change may begin with genuinely listening, recognising our vulnerability, accepting another perspective or taking one small step beyond our habitual behaviour.

What would it take for you to wake up to your own truth?

My Articles

Scroll to Top